“How Would You Feel If the Circumstances Were Reversed?”: Dr. Bradley Foerster Told SACUA the Hall Render Report Had Been Withheld, Remained Marked “Draft,” and the Investigation Was “Flipped” Against Him

On May 1, 2019, Dr. Bradley Foerster appeared before a University of Michigan Senate Advisory Committee on University Affairs review committee during the appeal of the Medical School’s recommendation to dismiss Dr. Foerster from a tenured faculty appointment.

After approximately 20 minutes, committee chair Professor Karen Staller stated that about ten minutes remained and asked Dr. Foerster to summarize the most important points in the written statement. Dr. Foerster agreed to “cut to the end.”

The closing statement began with a question: How had a successful University of Michigan student, resident, and faculty member come to be portrayed, within a relatively short period, as “the most unprofessional, uncredible, deceitful, irresponsible faculty member” at the University?

Dr. Foerster told the committee that although the proceedings concerned employment, the central issue was credibility and the damage to Dr. Foerster’s personal and professional reputation:

Although these proceedings were called regarding my employment status and standing at the University of Michigan, that is not the core issue at hand.

The real issue at hand and before you today is my very credibility and the numerous injustices, civil rights and Constitutional rights violations I have inexplicably faced here at the University of Michigan.

Dr. Foerster asked the committee to restore both the faculty position and Dr. Foerster’s reputation. The remainder of the statement asked the committee members to consider the record from the other side:

How would you feel if the circumstances were reversed?

The first questions concerned Dr. Foerster’s support for a young Muslim woman who had reported sexual harassment. Dr. Foerster asked how the committee members would feel if they had supported her, reported the concerns to the Office for Institutional Equity, waited nearly a year for the investigation, and then learned that 13 of their 17 evidentiary submissions had not been included in the report and that they could not appeal the finding of insufficient evidence.

The statement then turned to the Hall Render NIH-grant investigation :

How would you feel that after reporting your concerns as a whistleblower of improper NIH grant conduct to internal parties, that the report of the investigation was withheld from you for nearly a year, the investigation report reads “Draft copy,” and the investigation was “Flipped” on you to justify your termination?

The passage begins near the bottom of transcript page 133 and continues onto page 134. The issue was therefore directly before SACUA in May 2019.

The same concern appeared in the discussion of the EPIC medical-billing investigation:

How would you feel if you supported a colleague in reporting concerns of billing fraud per your employer’s guidelines and then you were retaliated against?

The questions then moved through the handling of the NIH grant, disputed grant funds, a compliance review conducted during medical disability, restrictions on additional NIH applications, and the return of grant funds.

Dr. Foerster also emphasized that allegations of incivility, obstruction, untrustworthiness, creation of a hostile work environment, and harm to the University’s reputation had been made without supporting evidence.

The statement next described consequences extending beyond the Medical School: psychiatric evaluations and a drug test; University police investigations conducted without Dr. Foerster’s knowledge; an unidentified witness whose allegations were used in a police investigation that froze Dr. Foerster’s bank accounts; and the resulting loss of Dr. Foerster’s home and assets. Dr. Foerster asked how the committee would feel if litigation undertaken to protect constitutional rights were later used to justify dismissal.

The reporting itself was expressly identified as protected activity:

How would you feel if you worked in a hostile work environment as result of your protected activity of reporting per University guidelines…

Dr. Foerster also asked how the committee would feel if hacked or stolen personal recordings and emails were used to justify dismissal.

When the allotted time expired, Chair Staller stated, “I want you to finish,” and the closing statement continued.

The final questions returned to the evidence and the fairness of the proceedings. Dr. Foerster noted that outside counsel had devoted nine pages of a 20-page appeal memorandum to attacking Dr. Foerster’s credibility, then asked:

How would you feel if you were not allowed to confront your accusers directly and instead the evidence presented for your dismissal was predominantly based on hearsay?

How would you feel if your employer did not allow you to view evidence as well as suppress critical evidence to mount a reasonable defense?

The statement also addressed interference with outside employment:

How would you feel if after securing new outside employment that the University/University affiliate sabotaged your new employment?

Dr. Foerster concluded by asking the committee to apply SACUA’s own due-process standards:

In conclusion, Committee, I respectfully ask that this Committee ask themselves each of these questions and rule accordingly. As I’ve informed my former chair Dr. Reed Dunnick many times, “It is never too late to do the right thing.”

Chair Staller’s first question was whether Dr. Foerster had received a formal outside employment offer. Dr. Foerster answered that a formal offer had been received that weekend and that the supporting email could be provided to the committee. The Maryland offer became part of the SACUA record.

Twenty-Three Days Later

On May 24, 2019, SACUA issued its final report . The committee addressed several procedural objections and excluded some matters as grounds for dismissal, including the VA grant issue, the VA termination, the absence of character witnesses, and Dr. Foerster’s civil litigation.

SACUA addressed the inability to confront certain witnesses by concluding that the case supporting dismissal rested on authenticated documentary rather than testimonial evidence. SACUA also discussed the Hall Render reports as documentary evidence and stated that the investigations had not originally been undertaken to support dismissal.

The report did not directly address the omission of 13 of 17 submissions from the OIE report; the nearly year-long withholding and “Draft” status of the Hall Render report; the use of protected reporting activity against Dr. Foerster; the restriction or suppression of evidence needed for a defense; or the claimed interference with Dr. Foerster’s outside employment offer.

Dr. Foerster ended the closing statement by asking SACUA to apply its own TriCampus due-process position.

The document Dr. Foerster invoked—the TriCampus Committee Resolution on Due Process—states in Section B(2), “Principles Regarding Sanctions”:

“Sanctions should not be imposed against a faculty member who was not the subject of the investigation, or who made the investigated complaint (including witnesses), unless a separate complaint and investigation took place regarding his/her own conduct. Findings and sanctions against complainants or witnesses in the absence of separate complaints and investigations (afforded the complainant or witness in the role of a respondent) shall be considered retaliatory.”

SACUA’s final report did not mention the TriCampus Committee Resolution on Due Process or analyze this standard. Instead, SACUA characterized Dr. Foerster’s defense as largely based on a “complex, conspiratorial, and targeted retaliation campaign.” The report later stated that Dr. Foerster rejected conclusions reached after “seemingly thorough investigations” and upheld the recommendation for dismissal.

SACUA’s TriCampus Committee Resolution on Due Process

The complete position statement is reproduced below. The quoted provision appears on PDF page 3 under Section B(2), “Principles Regarding Sanctions.”

Complete Transcript Excerpt — SACUA Hearing, May 1, 2019

Transcript pages 130–141 are reproduced below. Page 130 records Chair Staller’s request that Dr. Foerster summarize the remaining presentation. The discussion of credibility and reputation begins on page 131. The statement that the NIH-grant investigation had been withheld, remained marked “Draft copy,” and was then “Flipped” against Dr. Foerster begins near the bottom of page 133 and continues onto page 134. The closing statement concludes on page 141 with: “It is never too late to do the right thing.”

Transcript Pages 130–141 — “How Would You Feel If the Circumstances Were Reversed?”: Protected Reporting, Withheld Evidence, and Due Process

Author Image

Brad Foerster, MD PhD

Brad Foerster is a FOIA advocate documenting requests, transparency disputes, and accountability investigations involving public agencies, universities, police oversight, and Russia-Gate related inquiries. His work compiles original documents, timelines, and analysis of public records and institutional responses. Brad is also a board-certified radiologist, author of Town & Gown, and has published over 40 peer-reviewed articles. Brad lives in Potomac, Maryland with his family and is a member of the Montgomery County Medical Society and the Takoma Park U.S. & World History Book Club.