Dr. Bradley Foerster Sent “Tyson Howard” Months of NIH Grant Evidence—The Released FBI File Contains a Civil-Litigation “FYI,” but Not the Grant Emails

On March 2, 2018, Dr. Bradley Foerster and Dr. Myria Petrou were interviewed at the FBI’s Ann Arbor office by FBI Special Agent Sue Lucas and an individual presented as an HHS-OIG Special Agent. The individual identified himself as “Tyson Howard” and gave Dr. Foerster and Dr. Petrou an HHS-OIG business card bearing that name.

HHS-OIG had opened Case No. 5-17-0-0192-4 on October 6, 2017. Three days after the interview, the FBI opened Case No. 46H-DE-2595857 and requested a joint investigation with HHS-OIG. HHS-OIG closed the investigation on August 21, 2019.

With the exception of the September 7, 2021 FOIA follow-up, every email presented below was sent while the HHS-OIG investigation remained open.

Dr. Foerster repeatedly wrote to tyson.howard@oig.hhs.gov, the address printed on Howard’s business card. The emails addressed the records underlying the investigation, a disputed Utah subcontract, grant finances, the investigation’s effect on Dr. Foerster’s career, and requests for Howard’s assistance.

Howard never replied to any of the emails presented here.

The 2016 and 2017 NIH Annual Reports

On August 12, 2018, Dr. Foerster told Howard that the University of Michigan was pressing Dr. Foerster to approve a Utah subcontract for Spring 2018, although, according to the email, the grant was frozen and the IRB discontinued during that period.

The email tied the subcontract concern directly to the grant’s 2016 and 2017 annual reports. Dr. Foerster told Howard that those reports documented the absence of work by Robert Welsh and that the documented absence had prompted the request for an OIG investigation.

Dr. Foerster also wrote that Dr. Reed Dunnick had assumed the role of “managing PI” and, according to Dr. Foerster’s understanding, approved earlier subcontract requests. Dr. Foerster asked whether approving a subcontract for a frozen period would violate University or federal policy.

August 12, 2018 — “Update—Utah Subcontract Concerns for NIH R01NS082304”

Status of the Investigation

On July 15, 2018, Dr. Foerster requested an update on the investigation. The email included earlier follow-ups sent on June 19 and July 9.

July 15, 2018 — “Status of OIG Investigation NIH Grant R01NS082304”

On July 31, Dr. Foerster asked Howard whether Dr. Foerster was a target of the HHS-OIG investigation. The email explained that the University was invoking the unresolved OIG investigation to prevent Dr. Foerster from applying for external funding— described in the email as “the lifeblood of a tenure faculty.”

July 31, 2018 — “OIG Investigation”

Grant and Financial Records

On September 11, 2018, Dr. Foerster sent Howard a 21-page collection of University correspondence concerning Dr. Dunnick’s managing-PI role, the University of Utah subcontract, and the handling of the grant’s progress reports. The packet also included Dr. Foerster’s March 14, 2018 email to Vice President Timothy Lynch concerning Duaa Altaee’s sexual-harassment case, the University’s handling of that matter, and the resulting consequences for R01NS082304.

September 11, 2018 — “Evidence for NIH R01 Grant NS082304”

On September 20, Dr. Foerster sent financial records identifying $1,541,752.29 in NIH disbursements and $1,331,689 in University expenditures. The records came from different reporting systems and dates. The email presented the approximately $210,000 difference as a question requiring examination, not as proof that funds had been misused.

September 20, 2018 — “Financial Information for NIH Grant R01NS082304”

Financial records identified in the September 20 email

Requests for Action

On October 29, 2018, Dr. Foerster asked Howard to provide evidence or testimony during the University’s dismissal proceedings and to forward the request to FBI Special Agent Sue Lucas.

October 29, 2018 — “Witness Testimony”

On December 3, Dr. Foerster requested an explanation after the University represented that the grant had been closed in good standing while the federal investigation reportedly remained open.

December 3, 2018 — “Follow-Up”

On June 10, 2019, Dr. Foerster forwarded Howard a request sent earlier that day to NIH Director Deborah Kearse seeking a new investigation of R01NS082304 based on newly uncovered information and evidence. The forwarded request referenced Exhibits A–P and 23 additional records that Dr. Foerster stated Kara Morgenstern had not provided during the earlier investigation despite assurances that the records would be forwarded.

Dr. Foerster also told Howard that Hall Render had never interviewed Dr. Robert Welsh and recalled Howard stating in July 2018 that Howard had not interviewed Dr. Welsh either. The same email documented numerous unanswered emails, a fax, and a voicemail and asked Howard to confirm Howard’s identity, HHS-OIG employment, and participation in the March 2 interview.

June 10, 2019 — “Request for Investigation of NIH R01 Grant NS082304”

What Appears in the Released FBI File

The final FBI FOIA release contains two communications sent to Howard’s HHS-OIG address.

The first is an October 8, 2018 email forwarding a discussion of possible civil litigation. Dr. Foerster sent the forwarded discussion to Howard with the single notation, “FYI.”

October 8, 2018 — “Re: Meeting to Discuss Possible Lawsuit?”

The second is Dr. Foerster’s September 7, 2021 email asking Howard to explain why HHS-OIG could not locate the requested documentation of the March 2 interview.

The September 7 email followed the August 27, 2021 HHS-OIG FOIA determination , which reported that HHS-OIG’s search could not locate the requested reports of the interview.

September 7, 2021 — “No Official Record of Tyson Howard March 2, 2018 Interview of Foerster & Petrou”

The released FBI file does not contain the investigation-period emails presented above concerning the annual reports, Utah subcontract, financial records, investigation status, requested testimony, or requests for confirmation of Howard’s identity and role.

HHS-OIG Case 5-17-0-0192-4 Documentary Chronology
← Previous | Return to HHS-OIG Documentary Chronology | Next →

Author Image

Brad Foerster, MD PhD

Brad Foerster is a FOIA advocate documenting requests, transparency disputes, and accountability investigations involving public agencies, universities, police oversight, and Russia-Gate related inquiries. His work compiles original documents, timelines, and analysis of public records and institutional responses. Brad is also a board-certified radiologist, author of Town & Gown, and has published over 40 peer-reviewed articles. Brad lives in Potomac, Maryland with his family and is a member of the Montgomery County Medical Society and the Takoma Park U.S. & World History Book Club.