“His Denials Are Not Credible”: University of Michigan Outside Counsel Daniel Tukel Makes Dr. Bradley Foerster’s Credibility Central in 20-Page SACUA Response
On February 27, 2019, SACUA established the scope of its review of the recommendation to dismiss Dr. Bradley Foerster. Daniel Tukel of Butzel Long served as outside counsel for Dean Marschall Runge and the Medical School.
The Review Committee identified five questions:
- Were the Bylaw 5.09 procedures followed?
- Was the hearing fair?
- Did the findings correspond to the charges?
- Did the proceeding raise matters of broader University concern?
- Did the evidence support the findings and recommendation for dismissal?
Dr. Foerster’s memorandum was due March 18. Tukel received a copy and was given until April 10 to submit the Medical School’s response. Each side was limited to 20 pages.
Dr. Foerster’s March 18 Memorandum
Dr. Foerster’s 20-page memorandum addressed SACUA’s five questions and identified specific procedural, evidentiary, and constitutional objections.
The two Hall Render reports were the only materials among the Medical School’s 55 exhibits provided to Dr. Foerster before the tenure-dismissal hearings. Both were unsigned and marked “DRAFT.” The memorandum also challenged the inability to confront witnesses and the consideration of conduct beyond the stated charges.
The First Amendment objection was explicit: using civil-court proceedings to support dismissal would chill a faculty member’s right to seek judicial redress. The memorandum separately identified Dr. Foerster’s reporting as protected activity under Title IX, University policy, and whistleblower protections. It also invoked the SACUA TriCampus Committee Resolution on Due Process.
The Medical School’s April 8 Response
Tukel submitted a 20-page response on April 8—21 days after receiving Dr. Foerster’s memorandum and two days before the deadline.
The response identified all five review questions and stated that each favored dismissal. Pages 1–3 addressed compliance with Bylaw 5.09 and the fairness of the hearing. Page 3 addressed the relationship between the findings and the original charges. Pages 3–4 addressed whether the case involved matters of general University concern or primarily concerned the Medical School. The remainder addressed whether the evidence supported dismissal.
Tukel devoted pages 12–14 to “Credibility” and pages 15–20 to “Dr. Foerster’s Allegations of Error.” The response used Dr. Foerster’s civil litigation both to support allegations of professional misconduct and to undermine Dr. Foerster’s credibility.
Tukel stated that reporting fraud was not itself the issue; according to the Medical School, the allegations were false and had been improperly presented and disseminated as fact. The response did not address the First Amendment objection to using Dr. Foerster’s civil litigation in the dismissal case.
“9 of the 20 Pages”
Dr. Foerster raised the allocation of Tukel’s response during the May 1 hearing:
“[T]he outside attorney … spends 9 of the 20 pages in his memorandum attacking your credibility and your quote ‘Allegations of error’ end quote, instead of following the guidelines of the SACUA appeal hearings.”
The nine pages consisted of the three-page credibility section and the six-page response to Dr. Foerster’s alleged errors. Tukel had addressed SACUA’s five questions; Dr. Foerster’s statement challenged the emphasis of the response, nearly half of which focused on credibility and claimed errors.
Elsewhere in the May 1 closing statement , Dr. Foerster asked SACUA to consider withheld evidence, the use of constitutional litigation to support dismissal, interference with outside employment, and an investigation that had been “flipped” against the reporting faculty member.
Twenty-Three Days Later
On May 24, 2019, SACUA issued its final report . SACUA excluded Dr. Foerster’s civil litigation as an independent ground for dismissal because it did not primarily concern the Medical School.
The report did not determine whether Dr. Foerster’s litigation and protected reporting had already influenced the broader findings concerning credibility, character, and professional conduct. SACUA also did not decide the First Amendment objection raised in Dr. Foerster’s March 18 memorandum.
That exclusion did not end the matter. Dean Marschall Runge later reintroduced Dr. Foerster’s civil-litigation conduct in recommending dismissal . President Mark Schlissel relied on Dr. Foerster’s conduct in the judicial system and the committees’ adverse credibility findings in the final recommendation for dismissal .
The NIH Kearse Memorandum Enters the SACUA Record
Tukel’s April 8 response introduced the NIH Division of Program Integrity memorandum signed by Director Deborah Kearse into the 5.09 record as new Exhibit 9. Tukel quoted the memorandum’s conclusion that NIH had identified no improper salary payments to Dr. Robert Welsh and relied on that conclusion to characterize the NIH-grant allegations as false and to further challenge Dr. Foerster’s credibility.
The memorandum was incorrectly date-stamped January 2, 2018. Tukel acknowledged in a footnote that the year was incorrect and stated that the University did not receive the memorandum until January 2019—after the Ad Hoc Committee hearings and dismissal recommendation. Tukel also attached Kearse’s January 2, 2019 transmittal email as Exhibit 10. NIH later formally confirmed that the memorandum’s correct date was January 2, 2019.
The corrected date is significant. The final Research Performance Progress Report, submitted on October 30, 2018, did not attribute any specific research activity or data analysis to Dr. Welsh during the final reporting period and listed only 0.1 calendar month of effort for Dr. Welsh. This was despite a May 31, 2017 amendment that increased by $202,013 the University of Utah subaward supporting Dr. Welsh’s participation in the grant during the final grant year, May 1, 2017 through April 30, 2018.
More recently, Dr. Foerster asked Director Kearse to confirm whether the final RPPR had been reviewed as part of the assessment closed on January 2, 2019. On May 5, 2026, citing NIH’s inability to release nonpublic information concerning the specific actions taken during the review, Director Kearse declined to provide that factual clarification .
On May 26, 2026, Dr. Foerster asked Director Kearse whether the memorandum should be clarified, supplemented, amended, or reconsidered in light of the final RPPR and the University of Utah subcontract and accounting records. No response has been received to date.
Primary Documents
Document 1 — February 27, 2019 Notice of Review and Scheduling Order
PDF pages 1–3 establish the five review questions, the March 18 deadline for Dr. Foerster’s memorandum, the 20-page limit, and the April 10 deadline for the Medical School’s response.
Document 2 — Selected Pages From Dr. Foerster’s March 18 Memorandum
The selected pages document the pre-hearing evidence-access issue, the express First Amendment objection, and Dr. Foerster’s concluding responses to SACUA’s five questions. The complete March 18 memorandum and page-referenced analysis are available separately.
Document 3 — Daniel Tukel’s April 8 Response for the Medical School
The complete 20-page response is reproduced below. Page 12 has been redacted to protect information covered by a confidentiality agreement. The exhibits appended to the original filing are not reproduced.
View or download Daniel Tukel’s complete 20-page April 8, 2019 response memorandum.
Document 4 — May 1, 2019 SACUA Transcript, Page 140
Transcript page 140 records Dr. Foerster’s statement that Tukel devoted “9 of the 20 pages” to credibility and “Allegations of error.”
5.09 Documentary Chronology
← Previous
|
Return to 5.09 Documentary Chronology
|
Next →
Selected Reporting
- Bradley Foerster Submits 140-Exhibit, 1,121-Page Documentary Chronology to FBI for Supervisory Review of the Investigation Involving Dr. Bradley Foerster, Dr. Myria Petrou, and Duaa Altaee
- From One FBI File to a Legislative Proposal: Peter and Maria Foerster Ask Senator Van Hollen's Office and Congressman Jamie Raskin to Consider a Uniform Administrative Framework for Federal Investigations
- Eva Feldman Documentary Chronology: 139 Exhibits on NIH R01NS082304, University Proceedings, and Federal Investigation — No Response Received
- Bradley Foerster and Myria Petrou Send Ann Arbor Officials Documentary Chronology on AAPD and Related Federal Investigations — No Response Received
- Timothy Lynch Documentary Chronology: 63 Exhibits on University of Michigan Office of General Counsel, University Investigations, and Law Enforcement — No Response Received
- Bradley Foerster and Myria Petrou Documentary Chronology: 8 Exhibits Document More Than Two Years of Efforts to Trace Bank of Ann Arbor's $1.4 Million Sheriff's Sale Credit Bid — No Response Received