Reconstructing the NIH ALS Grant Investigation Across HHS-OIG and the FBI: Dr. Bradley Foerster’s Litigated University of Michigan FOIA Appeal Over a Withheld FBI Record Concerning Foerster and Dr. Myria Petrou

The University of Michigan first told Dr. Bradley Foerster that no records matched a request for FBI-generated documents concerning Dr. Foerster and/or Dr. Myria Petrou. After Dr. Foerster appealed, the University corrected the answer: one responsive FBI-generated record existed, but the University would withhold the entire record. The President’s Office upheld the withholding on November 19, 2026. The Michigan Court of Claims received Dr. Foerster’s complaint the next day.

The request followed years of FOIA research by Dr. Foerster and Dr. Petrou concerning NIH grant R01NS082304, on which Dr. Foerster was a co-principal investigator. In July 2017, Dr. Petrou filed an HHS-OIG complaint concerning fellow co-principal investigator Dr. Robert Welsh’s work and contractual obligations to the NIH under the grant. HHS-OIG marked the complaint administratively closed without Dr. Petrou’s knowledge.

A second complaint concerning University Radiology medical billing appeared under Dr. Petrou’s name without Dr. Petrou’s knowledge. Dr. Petrou later disassociated from the medical billing complaint.

FOIA releases raised further questions. A February 21, 2019 FBI record documented a conversation with personnel from the University’s Office of the Vice President and General Counsel and an HHS-OIG special agent concerning the grant. Released versions of the record reported that Dr. Foerster and Dr. Petrou were “in the process of being debarred” from future federal grants. The assigned Assistant U.S. Attorney advised that no criminal charges would be brought.

The conversation occurred during Dr. Foerster’s University 5.09 proceedings. Neither Dr. Foerster nor Dr. Petrou had been informed of the reported debarment process or the Assistant U.S. Attorney’s involvement. A December 2019 FBI case-closure record reported that the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Michigan declined criminal prosecution. The same record stated that HHS would pursue debarment; the record did not report a completed debarment.

Later HHS-OIG searches found no responsive debarment records for Dr. Foerster or Dr. Petrou. Searches of the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Michigan found no responsive records concerning the HHS-OIG case, including a search using the FBI case number.

The documents concerning the NIH grant were spread across HHS-OIG, the FBI, and the University. HHS-OIG records documented the complaints and investigation. FBI records disclosed discussions about criminal charges and debarment. University FOIA responses identified FBI records previously released by the University and a separate FBI record now withheld in full. No single release told the whole story. Comparing records across those institutions led to the October 13 request.

The October 13, 2026 request sought FBI-generated records concerning Dr. Foerster and/or Dr. Petrou that came into the University’s possession on or after September 20, 2019. The request excluded University-created advice, summaries, and deliberations. The University had previously released other FBI-generated records concerning Dr. Foerster under FOIA. University counsel had also presented FBI records during Dr. Foerster’s 5.09 proceedings.

The University’s November 3 response said no responsive records existed. After Dr. Foerster appealed, the University identified one FBI-generated record and withheld the record in full under Michigan FOIA’s frank-communications exemption. The President’s Office acknowledged that the first denial was issued in error but upheld the corrected denial.

The Court of Claims complaint asks the Court to examine the actual FBI-generated record. The University must establish that the record qualifies as an advisory communication preliminary to a final agency decision when created. The University must also justify withholding under the public-interest balancing test for this particular instance and release any separable factual or other nonexempt material.

Dr. Foerster does not know whether the withheld record concerns Dr. Foerster, Dr. Petrou, or both. The contents remain unknown. After submitting the complaint, Dr. Foerster asked the University to release the record, or the separable nonexempt portions, to resolve or narrow the dispute and conserve the Court’s and the University’s resources.

Complete Court of Claims filing, including exhibits: View the full filing on Google Drive .

Document 1 — October 13, 2026 FOIA Request and Follow-Up Email

Document 2 — November 20, 2026 Court of Claims Complaint

Document 3 — November 20, 2026 Request to Release the Record

Russia-Gate Documentary Chronology
← Previous | Return to Russia-Gate Documentary Chronology | Next →

Author Image

Brad Foerster, MD PhD

Brad Foerster is a FOIA advocate documenting requests, transparency disputes, and accountability investigations involving public agencies, universities, police oversight, and Russia-Gate related inquiries. His work compiles original documents, timelines, and analysis of public records and institutional responses. Brad is also a board-certified radiologist, author of Town & Gown, and has published over 40 peer-reviewed articles. Brad lives in Potomac, Maryland with his family and is a member of the Montgomery County Medical Society and the Takoma Park U.S. & World History Book Club.